1. You have a sustainable source of wood.
Perhaps you live in a forest, or a relative has an orchard, or you live next to a timber yard, or you just inherited a derelict warehouse with a large collection of broken pallets. If you don't know where your wood is going to come from, then you will need to buy it. You may have thought that wood grows on trees. In fact wood does grow on trees, but those trees grow on land, and that land usually belongs to someone. The trees also play a major role in creating habitat for wildlife, and are acting as a sink of atmospheric carbon and a source of oxygen.2. You like chopping and storing wood, making fires and cleaning stoves and chimneys.
Having a wood burning stove is a lifestyle choice. That's another way of saying that it will take more time, cost more money and may be worse than the alternatives in various other ways. Wood needs to be chopped and stored where it will stay long enough to dry out, but not too long in the same place where it will attract insects and other undesirables. If you only occasionally want to burn stuff, it may be better to go camping. There are some great campsites that allow you to have a fire!3. You have no neighbours.
You may be planning to go off-grid, which is a great idea if you live away from civilisation, and this may go hand-in-hand with the first criteria. If you are in a residential area, your neighbours may not appreciate smoke getting into their washing. This article in the Huffington Post suggested that the most efficient wood-burning stove will put out the same levels of pollution as 18 diesel cars. Would you like a fleet of cars driving around your neighbourhood?4. You are going to get the most efficient model available, with a properly installed chimney.
Benjamin Franklin did make significant improvements to stove design back in the 1700s, but even in the 1800s wood burning stoves were only 30% efficient. They sent out particles at levels that would be illegal today, and allowed creosote to build up in chimneys, creating a fire hazard.5. Your wood burning stove can run on pellets.
Part of the problem is the wood itself. It seems that wood was not designed with burning efficiency as the first priority. Wood pellets provide a more even fuel and allow higher efficiency. Many wood pellets are currently made from sawdust or waste wood products. There are also pellets made from grass cuttings. If demand increases, wood will be cut directly to make pellets, which may remove some of the supply-end energy efficiency, but they will still burn cleaner.You may consider a dedicated pellet burner, which will be easier to clean, and easier to use since it feeds the pellets via a hopper and may be controlled by a thermostat and a timer. It will probably be cheaper to install since the unit usually has a heat exchanger so a simpler chimney can be used. If you're still wondering about the answer to question 1, wood pellets could be your answer.
6. You are only going to light your stove a few times a year, and are mostly getting the stove because it will look nice in your living room.
7. You know that if burning wood was the best way to stay warm, everyone would still be using it.
Most of us no longer send telegrams, spin yarn on spinning wheels, or nip down to the local smithy to get a horse shoe fixed. We stopped doing these things because of new technology that is cheaper and more time-effective. Burning wood will likely be more expensive and more time consuming than the options. Wood was our first fuel source; if wood produced more energy than fossil fuel reserves, we would never have deforested vast areas of the planet to mine coal or pipe oil and gas.There is an old saying: if God had not intended us to burn wood, he would never have invented matches. Actually that's not an old saying at all, I just made it up. But there is something natural and wholesome about a wood fire.
So how did you score? If you answered yes to most of them, you're good to go. If not, I recommend looking into heat pumps, either in self-contained air conditioning units, or producing hot water for radiators or underfloor piping.
Remember, taken in moderation, wood burning stoves can form part of a calorie-controlled energy diet for your planet!
References:
More details from the US Office of Energy Efficiency and Renewable Energy: Choosing and Installing Wood- and Pellet-Burning Appliances
Chapter on Energy Return on Investment (EROI) of Different Wood Products by Zdravko Pandur, Marijan Šušnjar, Marko Zorić, Hrvoje Nevečerel and Dubravko Horvat (2015)



